A couple of days ago, I came across a blog post about Pinterest’s sign up and use agreement. The post was written by a photographer and lawyer. While she is not giving people advice within her post, Why I Tearfully My Pinterest Inspiration Boards, she did reveal her take on what amounts to risky pinning.
The world wide web is loaded with material, from images and photography, to music, videos and text. Most of them are owned by someone. But, what if we give credit to the originating website or author when pinning? Then it should be okay, right? The answer is seemingly, not necessarily. Often, there is no way to know for certain who owns what out there. Bottom line is that Pinterest’s agreement outlines your risk as a user of their site – and that includes you agreeing to accept all risk for all your pins. In her post, Kirsten disillusions us, outlining one line in particular, in Pinterest’s use agreement: “YOU ACKNOWLEDGE AND AGREE THAT, TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT PERMITTED BY LAW, THE ENTIRE RISK ARISING OUT OF YOUR ACCESS TO AND USE OF THE SITE, APPLICATION, SERVICES AND SITE CONTENT REMAINS WITH YOU.”
I understand that Pinterest is fun to use, and most people feel that it’s harmless. Let me tell you why I feel a little differently, especially after these terms were brought to my attention. I am not new to the world wide web. I have created many websites over the years, for different ventures, ideas, and reasons. A couple of years ago, I received a certified letter (certified mail itself is usually a cause for concern), which was a demand for nearly $10,000, OR face the threat of formal lawsuit…because they claimed that one little image on our website was copyrighted – and not by us. This company, which sent us the letter, is in the business of protecting copyrighted images on behalf of owners. It seems technology allows digital discovery of images throughout the web. But the photo, we argued, was from one of our vendor’s websites, displaying their products, which we retail. How could we possibly be in any trouble for that? Well, it turns out our vendor didn’t seem to have the right or permission to use the image either – though they also didn’t seem to know or realize this. Who is who, and where it came from, and why, was all beside the point though, because they did not care, nor did they care that the image was promptly removed when brought to our attention.
So I had to wonder about this when I was first introduced to Pinterest, though people have a tendency to think that if everyone else is doing it, then it must be okay. I hate to admit that I can be one of those people too, (perhaps the proper term would be sheeple).
While Pinterest may differ slightly from the above comparison, and while I’m not saying this could happen as a result of its use, the post was still enlightening for me, and still left me remembering my stressful battle about one little image long ago. I am, in no way, recommending that anyone else do anything with this information. I’m merely sharing my own thoughts about the topic. I very recently discovered Pinterest, so I have not had an opportunity to develop much of an attachment to my boards, but I can understand how others may feel very differently. I still love the site, and I may still browse through other’s boards because it’s still fun. I can still be inspired there, because there is plenty of inspiring pins. But I will think twice before pinning.
2 Comments »